Emma Watson’s Unexceptional, Somewhat Ignorant Speech

Emma Watson, at the UN
Emma Watson, at the UN

A young, educated, privileged, white woman-celebrity gets appointed a UN Women Goodwill Ambassador six months ago (UN Women is the United Nations organisation that works with women’s rights and issues). At the UN General Assembly, to launch a UN Women campaign on gender equality, this celebrity spokesperson, the Goodwill Ambassador, is asked to make a speech. She makes a speech — about gender equality.

THERE IS NOTHING AT ALL EXCEPTIONAL OR EXTRAORDINARY ABOUT THIS SITUATION. Emma Watson, 24, the star of the Harry Potter film franchise, basically did what was expected of her, as the Goodwill Ambassador for a UN organisation, at a major UN event. Here is the transcript of the speech, which much of the media, online and off, praised for being ‘game-changing’, and ‘smart, important, sociologically informed and compelling’.

When I finally got down to actually watching her speech, intrigued by what all the fuss was about, I went from being simply bored to actually frustrated. The call for everyone — men and women — to participate in the women’s rights movement is not new. The idea that gender stereotypes are bad and destructive for us all is not new. Many more have spoken about how the word ‘feminism’ has taken on negative connotations for the post-feminist generation, my generation: that’s not some ground-breaking revelation ‘her research’ has revealed. There is nothing game-changing about a celebrity ambassador making a speech on the topic relevant to her appointment as ambassador, at an event organised by the people who appointed her.

By now, I’m sure you’ve also realised that the ‘threats’ levelled against her by ‘hackers’ — threatening that nude photos of her would be leaked on to the internet — were false. This scandal was created by a notorious super-troll community 4chan and their site /b/; even the simplest Wikipedia read gives you enough information to know that ‘Gawker once jokingly claimed that “reading /b/ will melt your brain”‘, and that they are more or less always linked to glamorous online pranks.

Emma Watson’s speech was just a wasted opportunity. Standing there and telling us things that we have all heard before — from women far braver than she, women who have had far less opportunity to be seen and heard than she has had, women who have suffered indignity and violence in order to stand and say those things, women who have sacrificed their freedom, their lives to make that very point, women who have risen to the occasion to speak out after being at the receiving end of gender-based discrimination or violence themselves — she does not stop to remember any of these women, this entire movement that has gone before her, and continues to rise around her. She does not stop to applaud the men and women fighting this battle of inequality around the world, in far more severe circumstances: in situations of war, conflict and religious extremism, against deeply ingrained cultural dogma, against socio-economic, socio-political and socio-cultural structures.

Though she begins by saying we must reclaim the word ‘feminist’, she does not even directly stand up for the word or the movement; instead, in a cop-out move, she merely says, ‘And if you still hate the word, it is not the word that is important. It’s the idea and the ambition behind it,‘. She then does what a lot of young women seem to feel the need to do these days: she feels the need to say ‘Feminism is not man-hating’. She can only dismiss the idea of ‘man-hating’ itself so completely because she refuses to  acknowledge where the association comes from; because she does not acknowledge the history of feminism, she cannot understand the possible influence that this very ‘man-hating’ has had on our generation. She cannot understand that it is our privilege to be able to say ‘we do not hate men’, because feminists from a generation ago did what they felt was necessary, never once caring about how it made them look. ‘Public image’ wasn’t exactly at the top of their list of priorities. She cannot understand that ‘man-hating’ was indeed once the only choice, if you took into account centuries of blatant oppression, discrimination, and violence, at every level of life; it was the only way. Why is it so hard to defend feminism, the idea of equality for all, totally? Why the need to make these justifications and excuses?

The call for male participation in the struggle for women’s rights is something we have heard before; it’s crucial, but it’s a tricky business. The UN Women campaign HeForShe itself seems slightly problematic — is it placing too much importance on revealing what we suppose is the natural virtue and respectability of the man? Isn’t it basically just a ‘clean-up your image’ campaign for men? Isn’t it just asking, once again, that we restore honour and glory to the image of the man? I’m not sure.

All it was, was a publicity campaign, an advertisement, for the HeForShe campaign, to be launched by UN Women. Let’s just take a moment to acknowledge that: that is all Goodwill Ambassadors are; they are advertisements, advertisers. As Watson so cleverly puts, once again dodging the work of actually standing up for the feminist movement itself, instead selling the campaign: ‘We are struggling for a uniting word, but the good news is, we have a uniting movement. It is called HeForShe.’

Watson’s speech and the subsequent media-fuss reveals to us perfectly that none of this is about ‘feminism’ or gender equality at all. It’s a reassertion of the monopoly of the Western, capitalist narrative over all other narratives in the mainstream, even when we’re talking of rights. It’s great if we are actually thinking more about gender itself, drawing our own attention to the problems with patriarchy for us all, as a society, and the need of male participation in the women’s rights movement. But, really, are we?

 

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “Emma Watson’s Unexceptional, Somewhat Ignorant Speech

  1. This blog post totally missed the point of Miss Watson’s speech. Seems this blogger is yet another self absorbed, narrow minded, outmoded feminist hating on the He for She movement. I want my time back for reading this unsubstantiated tripe… I have a son and a daughter and the He for She movement is about ensuring both of them have a future without gender bias, stereotypes and inequality. In 2014 the issues at stake for our future generations is bigger than feminism. Inequality has a very far reach from race to religion to skin colour and gender. He for She is about bringing awareness to the bigger picture and empowering humanity in the process. Maybe this blogger should do more research before defaming organisations and their respecive ambassadors. Shameful…

  2. Thank you so much for this piece of writing. It brings a sharp analysis of what is happening with men’s involvement in gender equality. I have been working on challenging patriarchal ideas of manhood and masculinity over last 15 years and realized that men do understand and adapt language of equality and remain far far from real personal transformation. Their personal privileges hardly become political…after going through many many such stories of fake transformation now what i believe is that there is no point talking about masculinity without feminism

  3. Heforshe is nothing but just a patriarchal protectionist approach that UN is advertising…. writer rightly captures the larger thinking and perception….. kudos….

  4. Right on stating this is ignorant, I dont understand how she can represent women and adress the men in that way, She has not lived through enough hasnt lived with a man, Married or given birth to know and feel how important this “role” of hers is. As a woman and now in the public. The roles men play since the dawn of time is equally important, but that again is something you have to live through to understand, What are you going to tell Managers with pregnant workers? What is maternity leave equal to men? Dont give us this silly girl in the first world to to talk for US women.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s